What I learned about Japanese mascara mastery during my time in Tokyo
Walking through the beauty aisles of any Tokyo drugstore, you’ll notice something immediately: the mascara selection is overwhelming, and one brand appears everywhere. From the makeup pouches of commuters on the Yamanote Line to the beauty counters of every Japanese beauty store, Heroine Make mascara has achieved something remarkable – it’s a staple in many Japanese woman’s makeup collection.
I first discovered this mascara back in 2016 during my early Tokyo days, featuring it in one of my first Japanese drugstore beauty roundups. But I’ll be honest – I almost passed it by. The bright, anime-inspired packaging made me wonder if it was marketed toward teenagers or if the result would look more cosplay than everyday chic. I couldn’t have been more wrong. Nearly a decade later, after testing hundreds of mascaras from around the world, Heroine Make Long & Curl remains my gold standard. That kind of lasting loyalty isn’t just about nostalgia – there’s genuine innovation behind this cult status, rooted in nearly 200 years of Japanese beauty expertise.
The Company Behind the Magic: A Beauty Legacy Since 1825
Heroine Make is produced by Isehan, and here’s a fact that stopped me in my tracks when I first learned it: Isehan is Japan’s oldest cosmetics company, founded in 1825. That’s not just old – that’s two centuries of understanding Japanese women’s beauty needs, climate challenges, and lifestyle demands.
To put this in perspective, when Isehan was founded, Japan was still in the Edo period. This company has witnessed and adapted to every major change in Japanese society, from the Meiji Restoration to post-war reconstruction to the modern era of 12-hour workdays and humid summers. That kind of institutional knowledge doesn’t just disappear – it gets refined and perfected with each generation.
What I Discovered About Japanese Mascara Technology
Living in Tokyo taught me that Japanese mascaras aren’t just different – they’re solving completely different problems than their Western counterparts. The breakthrough lies in what Japanese brands call “film technology,” which Western beauty enthusiasts know as tubing mascara.
Instead of coating lashes with the traditional wax-and-pigment formula that can smudge, flake, and fail in humidity, film technology creates microscopic polymer tubes around each individual lash. These tubes are flexible, moving with your natural lash movement rather than cracking or breaking down throughout the day.
But here’s where Japanese innovation goes further: while Western tubing mascaras focus primarily on the tube-forming technology, Japanese brands like Heroine Make combine this with meticulously engineered brushes and formulas specifically designed for Asian climates and lifestyles.
Why Tokyo Women Swear By It: The Real-World Test
Tokyo summers are brutal for makeup. Humidity regularly reaches 80%, sudden afternoon thunderstorms are common, and if you’re commuting on packed trains during rush hour, you’re essentially stress-testing your makeup in a sauna. Add 12-hour workdays and the cultural expectation to look polished from morning meetings to after-work socializing, and you understand why Japanese women need mascara that performs differently.
During my years in Tokyo, I watched women in Tokyo navigate these challenges with ease, and Japanese mascara like Heroine Make was consistently the secret weapon. After eight years of personal use, here’s what continues to impress me most:
Humidity Resistance: While my Western mascaras would start sliding within hours of Tokyo’s summer humidity, Heroine Make held strong.
Longevity: The film technology means the mascara doesn’t gradually wear away – it either stays perfect or comes off completely when you’re ready to remove it.
Curl Hold: This was the game-changer for me, and it makes perfect sense when you understand the context. Many Japanese women naturally have very straight eyelashes that point downward, making curl creation and retention absolutely critical. Japanese mascaras prioritize curl retention in a way that Western formulas simply don’t because they’re solving a more challenging baseline. After 12+ hours, the lift and curl remained intact – something that becomes even more impressive when you realize it’s holding a curl that wasn’t naturally there to begin with.
The Two Formulas: Long & Curl vs. Volume & Curl
Heroine Make offers two main variations, and understanding the difference changed how I approach mascara:
Long & Curl (Advanced Film): This is the precision tool of mascaras. The formula is designed to lift and extend while holding curl with impressive tenacity. The brush is smaller and more controlled, perfect for reaching every lash and creating that coveted “doll eye” effect that’s so popular in Japanese beauty culture.
Volume & Curl (Advanced Film): This brings drama while maintaining the curl-holding technology. The brush is fuller, the formula more building, but still maintains that film technology that prevents the clumping and flaking you’d expect from such an intensive formula.
Both formulas share that signature film technology, but they’re addressing different beauty goals within the same high-performance framework.
The Removal Revolution: Why You Need Their Mascara Remover
Here’s something that initially frustrated me but eventually became one of my favorite aspects of Japanese mascara: the removal process is completely different. Film technology creates such a strong, flexible coating that regular makeup remover or micellar water won’t budge it.
Enter Heroine Make’s Speedy Mascara Remover. This isn’t just a marketing upsell – it’s an essential part of the system. The remover is specifically formulated to dissolve the film tubes without harsh rubbing that can damage your lashes. You apply it, wait about 30 seconds, and the mascara slides off in perfect little tubes.
Initially, this seemed like an inconvenience. But after months of use, I realized this removal method is actually gentler on lashes than the aggressive rubbing required to remove waterproof Western mascaras.
The Economics: High Performance Cosmetics at Drugstore Prices
Perhaps the most shocking aspect of Japanese beauty culture is the price point. In Tokyo drugstores, Heroine Make mascara retails for around ¥1,200-1,500 (roughly $8-10 USD). Compare this to Western mascaras with similar performance claims that retail for $25-35, and you start to understand why Japanese women have such loyalty to domestic brands.
This isn’t about cutting corners – it’s about efficiency and market understanding. Japanese companies have perfected their domestic market to the point where they can offer superior performance at accessible prices.
Where to Find It: A Tokyo Shopping Guide
During my Tokyo years, I discovered the best spots to purchase Heroine Make:
Don Quijote: The chaotic wonderland of Japanese retail always stocks the full range, often with limited editions and promotional bundles.
Drugstore chains (Matsumoto Kiyoshi, Kokmin, Sundrug): These offer the most consistent stock and often run sales.
For international readers, the brand is increasingly available through online retailers, though authenticity verification is important given the popularity of counterfeits.
J-BEAUTY HUNT- Official Stockist in USA and ships internationally
Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara- Waterproof (Black)
Heroine Make Volume and Curl Mascara- Waterproof (Black)
Why This Matters Beyond Japan
What I learned living in Tokyo extends far beyond one mascara brand. It’s about understanding how different beauty cultures prioritise different solutions. Japanese beauty culture has spent centuries perfecting formulas for longevity, climate resistance, and gentle effectiveness – priorities that are becoming increasingly relevant globally as we face more extreme weather patterns and demanding lifestyles.
Heroine Make represents something larger: the value of institutional knowledge, cultural understanding of real-world beauty challenges, and the innovation that comes from truly understanding your consumer’s daily life.
The next time you’re frustrated with mascara that doesn’t hold curl, smudges in humidity, or requires aggressive removal, remember that there’s a solution that’s been refined for nearly 200 years. Sometimes the best beauty secrets aren’t secret at all – they’re just waiting on the other side of the world, perfected by women who understood these problems long before they became global concerns.
Have you tried Japanese mascaras? What was your experience? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to follow Tokyo Beauty Book for more insights from Japan’s innovative beauty culture.
Leave a Reply